top of page

What's Beneath the Ness of Brodgar? A Neolithic Mystery in Orkney

tourorkney
14 hours ago
4 min read


Why was a film crew setting up on the Ness of Brodgar, that little slip of land in the heart of Neolithic Orkney?

Because something important had been discovered. Something unexpected, and something that could write a new chapter in the history of the Ness of Brodgar.

But what is it they've found?

I have a theory.


The Ness of Brodgar: A Neolithic Vatican

Back in 2003, a strange notched stone was discovered in a field on the Ness of Brodgar.

A team of archaeologists came in to investigate, but they soon found this was part of a much larger complex of strange ceremonial buildings.

The way to think about it is like a Vatican of 5,000 years ago.

This little strip of land between the Loch of Stenness and the Loch of Harray was covered in buildings of all sorts of shapes and sizes. Some had walls several metres thick, decorated stones and elaborate interiors.

For hundreds of years, this seems to have been an extremely important site in Neolithic Britain.

But around 4,500 years ago, something happens.

Orkney is covered in standing stones, temples, tombs, cairns, all sorts of things built during the Neolithic Age.

But 4,500 years ago, there is a breakdown in culture.

The great period of monument building comes to an end. Buildings are abandoned, entranceways are filled in with stones and earth, and some of these sites appear to have been deliberately decommissioned.

At the Ness of Brodgar, building has stopped.

Towards the end of the site's use, a huge feast is held involving around 400 cattle.

Afterwards, their bones are deposited around one of the largest buildings, Structure Ten, and the great complex is eventually abandoned.

Something has changed.


A New Discovery Beneath the Ness of Brodgar

In 2024, after more than twenty years of digging, the archaeologists decided to close up the trenches.

They'd only dug around 10% of the site, but already had an enormous amount of material to study.

They said, listen, we need to start going through this. We can't dig up any more just now.

And so they filled it all back in.

Then in 2025, further geophysical surveys, including ground-penetrating radar, revealed something unexpected beneath the ground.

Something that didn't seem to fit with what had been found before.

But what had they found?

Well, I have a theory.

And it starts 450 miles south.

At Stonehenge.


Stonehenge and the Altar Stone

Stonehenge is probably the world's most famous stone circle.

It's built of enormous standing stones, some quarried in Wiltshire and others brought all the way from Wales.

But near the centre of Stonehenge lies something particularly interesting.

The Altar Stone.

It's an enormous sandstone slab weighing around six tonnes.

And what's boggled archaeologists for years is why it looks different from the other stones.

Then, in 2024, a study was published, and it was discovered that the Altar Stone didn't come from Wales, as had previously been thought.

Instead, its geological fingerprint pointed towards the Orcadian Basin in northern Scotland.

That's a geological region that includes Orkney and Caithness. More recent research has suggested parts of mainland northern Scotland are stronger possibilities, but the precise source remains uncertain.

So that stone has travelled more than 450 miles.

How do you move something that weighs six tonnes, 450 miles over land and sea?

Probably by boat.

Now, boats are a really interesting thing, because we haven't found any surviving seaworthy craft from Neolithic Britain capable of carrying such a load. But that doesn't mean there weren't any.

Somehow, someone got cattle up onto the Orkney Islands, so we're almost certain that there were seaworthy boats.

I believe there was some large vessel used to carry the Altar Stone down to Stonehenge.

That boat would then be brought back up to Orkney.

And being so important, like most of the other important sites, perhaps it had some ceremonial decommissioning.

And I think it might have been decommissioned here, at the Ness of Brodgar.

I think they could have buried it and surrounded it with earth, stones, bits of bones, bits of animals, bits of birds, all sorts of special objects.

Even if that vessel has rotted away and disappeared, those objects might have kept the shape of it.

And I think that's what they might have picked up on the radar scan.


From Orkney to Stonehenge

Now, why did they move it? Why from up in northern Scotland down to Stonehenge?

Because I think at one point Orkney was an extremely important place for Neolithic Britain.

I almost think this is where the winter solstice was celebrated, and then down south is where the summer solstice was celebrated.

Because what do we have up here?

We have the Mirrie Dancers — we have the Northern Lights.

And during winter, anyone who saw that would have thought, wow, this is the gods.

This is something so important.

But anyway, they move it, and 4,500 years ago is a really interesting time period because that is the dawning of the Bronze Age in Britain.

And where are the great sources of copper and tin needed for bronze? Down in the south and west of Britain, none up in Orkney.

So is that the point where Stonehenge now becomes the most important place, and that is the focal point from here on in?

And they start bringing in the important relics from roundabout Britain to this one site.

And that is how Orkney ended.



Explore Neolithic Orkney

The Ness of Brodgar is just one part of Orkney's extraordinary Neolithic landscape. On our Neolithic Wonders tour, we explore the standing stones, ancient settlements and burial chambers that have survived for thousands of years, and try to make sense of the people who built them.

Comments


"Ciaran grew up in the Scottish mountains and has guided travellers across the world — from white-water rivers to Highland trails. Featured in National Geographic and The Times, he lives on Orkney, where he leads private tours filled with history, folklore, and the stories you won’t find on the signs."

hello@tourorkney.com

tel: +44 (0) 7921888385

Victoria House, Stromness, Orkney Islands, KW16 3AJ

​

  • visitscotland
  • Orkney_edited
  • DestinationOrkney
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Facebook

©2027 by Tour Orkney. 

Rewilderness LTD. trading as Tour Orkney

bottom of page